It’s not every ep that gets a rhyme.
I can not give them credit for sticking the landing. If I never saw the show in previous years, I think I’d be impressed as hell! But I have been watching every ep, every year. That’s how I recognized how thoroughly Chibnall ripped off The Sound of Drums and several other old eps. Really, Russell T. Davie’s and Steven Moffat’s greatest hits.
It’s a shame because if I wasn’t constantly noticing all the unabashed nods to Blink, The Big Bang, even Age of Steel, Gridlock and the previously mentioned The Sound of Drums, I might have been fooled into thinking this was an original episode.
It being a Master episode, I can only guess Chibnall decided that he’d just take a bunch of story bits and plot devices from the penultimate episode of Series 3 and just throw them in. The “fam” on the run but now known worldwide as Most Wanted with their pictures on every screen. The heartsbeat of the Master, tap tap tap tap, three of them sitting around in a warehouse chatting and of course the raving mad dog version of the Master. Sacha Dhawan is a very good actor but half the time is playing the raving lunatic. It doesn’t serve him well.
Jodie does pretty well here, standing toe to toe with her arch nemesis. A shame the ep was such a mash of rehashing. The ending was strong though, even if Gallifrey being gutted is another repeat. The Fam finally asking her who exactly she is and her responding is well done too. Unfortunately, it opens up the can of worms.
With the gap year, they’ve been riding along with this galactic stranger for two years now, almost getting killed every week. They’re only *now* asking who she is?!?!? Seriously? She comes across as half insane half the time and they all should have died in the vacuum of space at the end of their very first adventure! –in fact there’s no way they didn’t but Chibs isn’t big on science.
The end discussion they have plainly states that in all this time, they haven’t sat down somewhere for a chat. In two years. Because anyone and everyone who would ever step inside the TARDIS, especially after almost dying, would be asking questions about *everything*. For god’s sake, Yaz is *supposed to be a cop*! She seriously doesn’t question the Doctor’s background for two YEARS? That’s what people do, but Chibs doesn’t get that for some reason. It’s as if he hasn’t had a lot of social interaction in his life.
And let’s talk about the “fam”. The three stooges. They’re utterly useless in this story. There’s no need for them. They’re nothing more than liabilities. Dangerous liabilities at that. Graham, usually the most beloved character of the series is made to be a dancing idiot with laser shoes. Yes, deadly lasers start shooting out of his feet in all directions because he has absolutely no control over them. Yes, Yaz should’ve probably taken one through the skull and Ryan should have lost a limb several times but it’s all funny, all Scooby Doo rascally fun. My wife suggested halfway through that the Doctor just send the three dopes back to 1834 and we’ll keep Aida, who was much smarter and far more competent a companion. Yaz and Ryan were also useless, idiotic, comic relief.
Other casualties of The can of worms being opened….
- The nazi’s are spraying bullets *all* over the floor with machine guns, just in case someone is hiding under the floor. They leave, satisfied. Then the woman spy native to the era (world famous spy they happen to run into immediately upon landing–coincidence), lifts up some floor boards and we see the Doctor and Aida laying there unhurt somehow. There was a rug over the section. Perhaps the nazi’s didn’t feel like shooting it? Nice pattern?
- The Master has done many horrible things, from multiple genocide to the burning of planets, but dressing as a Nazi is a “new low” for him? That scraping sound is my eyes rolling in an extreme manner.
- They showcase Aida, who’s technically the mother of the modern day computer, which is great, a real trailblazer. But for some reason, Chibs takes on a Nazi B story to wedge in the female trailblazer spy and she gets short shrift. I thought she’d get her own ep. Instead she gets jammed in on the side of this one. Pace yourself, Chibs, spread the wealth a bit more!
So yeah, we’re two eps in on S12, already 1/5th the way done and after a decent start, Chibs seems to be regressing again. Next week, ep 3 is “Orphan 55” written by Ed Hime, who wrote my favorite story if S11, “It Takes You Away”. I’m always more hopeful when Chibs isn’t writing, because the thing IS.







