Well, maybe. I’m referring to the CW’s biggestest most superest, powerfullest, superhero Crisis ever! Crisis on Infinite Earths is being spread out over five hours of tv. The first three parts have already aired this past December and the final two parts are airing next week. I’m chiming in now because right now, they’re cruising on a high note and frankly, I don’t know if they’re going to stick the landing.
Sticking the landing on any show or series is very important to me but that deserves its own entry. Here, we, and the producers of these shows, The Berlanti group, are kind of at the mercy of the “house style” of the CW. They seem to require their shows to add heavy doses of one on one talks, a lot of soap opera, and at times, apparently, idiocy and buffoonery.
Before jumping into my assessment of what’s gone before, during their normal runs, here’s what you can usually look forward to on any of these shows on a typical week. Supergirl– often uninteresting, rambling, and they make the lead character out to be mostly a whimpering idiot. Batwoman– so far in the short run, cool costume, not really ready for the mantle yet and spends too much time on one lame villain, her sister, who she “just knows she can save”. Flash–after losing their way a year ago with sitcom antics, this one’s greatest failing is a lot of sobbing and endless padding of a story. They made a four ep story go 23 eps last year. Black Lightning– most solid of the bunch on every level. Arrow was good after it ditched a lot of the extra soap opera but got to be repetitive and probably should have ended after S5 like they originally planned. Legends doesn’t take their heroes, threats or time travel seriously, it’s mostly just buffoonery and sitcom antics. The title is very misleading and frankly, unearned.
So far though, Crisis parts One, Two and Three just got better and better. Part One was, admittedly, crap. Maybe that’s because it was handled by the Supergirl team, I don’t know but even after finding out entire universes were dying, they found time for comedy bits and not so clever repartee. The whole shebang started with comedy. Well, if you can’t get Keaton to stage a dramatic Bat-cameo watching in anguish as his world is destroyed, I guess you get the next worse thing, Robert Wuhl sitting on a bench cracking a joke. We even see Burt Ward blurt out the obligatory “Holy…!” as he walks Ace the Bat-hound. They probably should have put a colorful sign around his neck that said “Ace the Bat-hound”.
You’re probably saying, “oh, who cares, they’re having fun!” Well sure they are, but they’re also supposed to be informing the audience that everything and everyone is being destroyed and that it’s obviously a very serious situation. But if they play it for laughs, like they do so many serious things in these shows….don’t expect us to respect your story or these heroes if *you* don’t respect them.
There was a lot of nonsense including a battle of time wraiths or something, necessitating both Green Arrow and Batwoman to jump a lot and spin in mid air for no reason as they took cover behind rocks and a needless death for Ollie that you knew wouldn’t take because it was lame. Lots of dumb stuff, illogical stuff. Gosh, Lois is just so witty and funny. Moving on.
Part One/Supergirl: 2 of 10.
Part Two was the Batwoman episode and I think this one started with the Huntress star from Birds of Prey from about 15 years ago. Here, we had her on the rooftops, playing a great cameo, trying to contact Oracle as she looked on in helpless anguish as her world then dies. That was chilling and quality. The other two highlights were Kevin Conroy playing a future Bruce Wayne/Batman and it was great to finally have the voice come alive and with a twist for his story, being the Batman that one day killed the Joker and once he crossed that line….
The other major appearance was the Kingdom Come Superman played by Brandon Routh and in one fell swoop, I hope it showed Warner Bros studios how Superman should look and how he should be played. Of course they won’t listen but if they were smart….. in any case, thanks to these guest appearances, this was a big step up. There was still some comedy and Batgirl and Supergirl were okay. Did I mention that Lois is funny and witty? Just so happens they’re pitching a Superman and Lois show.
Part Two/Batwoman: 6/10
The Flash hosted part three and here’s where they pretty much stopped the comedy finally because now I guess it dawned on them that of the millions of alternate universes, we were now down to only SIX. I guess that sobered up either them or the writers but this was a pretty tight hour of guest appearances and dramatic plot points. Tom Welling shows up as Clark, Routh is still there as the best super character in all these shows (definitely not the annoying Ray Palmer) and John Wesley Shipp returns as the Flash and Black Lightning arrives to make the assemblage even greater. The whole episode is handled with a quality that all these shows should be handled with each week, including pacing and action. Unfortunately, by the episode’s end, things look darker than ever as everything is eradicated except a handful of heroes, half of them non powered, to face one of the most powerful figures in what was once the Multiverse. A truly great set up.
Part Three/Flash: 8/10
Which leaves us next week with Part Four/Green Arrow and Part Five/Legends of the DC Universe. They’re gonna have to be because the thing IS.









