The reasons/excuses for why the Cubs have basically disintegrated over the last four years are plenty. Lack of home grown talent, the collective bargaining agreement, Ricketts not wanting to spend more, Dexter Fowler left, and we didn’t have a lead off guy, blah blah blah.
The Cubs actually had good pitching this year. You could still count on Lester, Hendricks was great, Mills impressed and Darvish…yikes, Darvish was a madman.
No, I’m not blaming the pitching, although Aldolay might also be coming up permanently as well and I think next year looks to be a good year for the Cubs’ rotation. No, the problem is hitting.
The down and dirty is that the Cubs’ position players are inconsistent hitters, doing barely enough to keep their heads above water during the regular season and become useless in the post season. During the regular season, they’ll score 10 runs one game, then none the next, one the next, none the next, none the next, 12 the next. They have one hot streak, then play .500 ball the rest of the way.
Everybody blames the manager (bye Joe), the hitting coaches (there’s a looong list over the past decade), *everybody* but the hitters.
Madden even read a book on the proper way to handle millennials. Seriously. Are they delicate flowers who’d rather screw around with Call of Duty and Tik-Tok, or they professional baseball players? You’ve got to “know how to talk to them without hurting their feelings?” Really? Please.
For some reason, Rizzo, Bryant, Baez, Schwarber, Horner, Bote, & co. are just failing. The boys keep talking about how Theo developed a “winning culture” but where’s it been? What actually goes on in that clubhouse?
*Something* is poisoning the crew and it’s been going on for years now.
You’ll notice it overtakes new players a while after they join. A couple years ago, Daniel Murphy joined. He came in like a house afire and was hitting like crazy. Then after a spell in the Cubs clubhouse, his bat slowed to a crawl like the rest. “One of us.” Same thing happened to Nick Castellanos last year. He was a one man run machine but at the end, he drank the dopey kool-aid. Jason Kipnis was this year’s zombie convert. Came in swinging and then, the rest of the Cubbies rubbed off on him. Ian Happ was a force of nature early this season, then bloop. Sleeeeep.
The only guy on the whole team that’s the outlier is Jason Hayward. This guy is a conundrum. When he got here, his first year at the plate was horrible, then each subsequent year, he consistently got a bit better. After like five years, last year he was finally good and this year he had a career year! I think he’s still got two or three years left on the whopper of a contract but hey, if he’s now worth it, great! Let’s keep HIM.
Maybe it’s the five star Hollywood hotel and spa the clubhouse became? It’s majestic in there. Maybe it’s so nice, the Cubs just got real comfortable. Too comfortable. I don’t know, but when they change the hitting coaches *several* times, and change the manager, yet the guys STILL aren’t hitting, you know where the problem is.
So, we know who the problem children are. What happens next?
It’s obvious by now that there’s some kind of attitude in that clubhouse amongst the majority of the hitters that says “we know what we’re doing, we don’t need help”. They’re wrong, they’re arrogant, they’re unwilling to learn and grow. They’re sipping from the punchbowl of poison kool-aid and it’s not healthy. So…
Kyle Schwarber – since rising from injury like a combination of Superman and Lazarus just in time for the 2016 World Series, we’ve now waited an extra FOUR YEARS for him to go back to being that guy again. He hasn’t. How much longer do we wait before trading him, selling him, you name it? He’s gotta go.
And don’t get me wrong, I’m sure they’re all good guys and kind to small animals but who is it helping to keep this damaged, restricted, close minded, “we won’t change” mentality around?
Kris Bryant — former MVP, ROY, and lately, mostly injured. And he’s been in more mental slumps, injury induced slumps and slumps by association than almost anyone. Do we trade and get a few prospects for him? Each year, I get the feeling his value is diminishing before our eyes, along with the integrity of his skeletal structure. Maybe he’d do a lot better with a change of scenery? A lot of fan’s will call me stupid to want to get rid of him because he’s so great. Well yeah, I guess we can just hold onto him for another year and see if he actually stays healthy and productive for entire season like he did in ’16, but I haven’t been seeing a lot of upward trending with him either. I’m tired of waiting. Goodbye, KB.
David Bote – opposing pitches have figured him out and he really hasn’t been a factor. What can we get for him? Go.
Ian Happ – seems like a smart dude and if he can keep the power going, he will be an MVP candidate. I think he just needs the poison clubhouse kool-aid taken away. Once away from it, I think he’ll thrive. Keep him, please.
Javier Baez – who can ever figure out Javy? He was the worst he’s ever been at the plate this year. Was it really having no fans in the stands that screwed him up, or was the distraction his wife and kids, or something else? He’s one of the best ever in the field and yet he’s Sybil at the plate. What do you do? No idea. He’s too entertaining to get rid of. Or is he?
Nico Hoerner – I think he’s got massive potential but again, too much of whatever bad influence is in that clubhouse, the kool-aid, whatever. Get rid of the punchbowl but give him another shot.
Wilson Contreras – he’s hot and cold at the plate but a great catcher with a big arm. His temper and his attitude works against him sometimes, but if he does some maturing, seems like he’s got potential to be even better than he’s gotten so far.
Victor Caratini – gotta keep him. He’s got decent numbers at the plate, although, sure, he could be better. He’s a very good catcher. But his greatest value is his synergy with Yu Darvish. They work very very well together. Once Caratini started catching Yu, Darvish resurfaced as one of the best pitchers in baseball and is in the mix for Cy Young this year. It would be a *big* mistake in my opinion to get rid of Vic.
Anthony Rizzo. This one’s tough. He’s the unofficial captain of the club but does that mean he’s also pouring the kool-aid? He’s usually had a good mindset about choking up on two strikes, and I admire the professionalism but I sometimes wonder about the guy. Is he sending the wrong vibe through the clubhouse? If a lot of the guys look to him for leadership, is he doing something wrong or is he not stepping up properly in the first place? Is he joking and entertaining, or is he inspiring and leading?
And although during the regular season, he’s usually Mr. Consistent with well above average stats, he’s usually hitless in the postseason, like most of these guys.
This core of guys is still mostly intact from 2016. Maybe they lost 25% of the crew. Arietta, Lackey, Zobrist, Montero, Russell, Chapman. Still, they had most of those guys for ’17 and still had some of them in ’18 and ’19. So, I’m not exactly sure what happened after ’16.
Arrogance? Complacency? Some mixture of both?
There’s no good excuse. This team was better than the Dodgers in ’16, yet the Dodgers mowed them down in ’17, and now, the Dodgers have gone to the World Series three times in the last four years. At the very least, the Cubs and Dodgers should have been going back and forth making WS appearances since ’16.
When you look at the Cubs’ core hitters on paper all this time, it’s been quite the murderers row. And ever since ’16, I figured it was just a matter of time before Rizzo, Bryant, Baez, Schwarber, Contreras, Zobrist, and Heyward, most or all of them would get hot and be unbeatable again. I waited. And waited. And waited. Never happened.
So, we can all keep waiting because of ’16, or get rid of the deadwood, I suppose.