I first was made aware of the Fantastic Four in the mid 1960’s– this was a few years before I started getting any comics. Yes, all my vast knowledge of the world is from sci fi and superheroes on tv. Both live action and animated. As it should be.
Hanna Barbera did a lot of this genre in the ’60’s but as far as Marvel went, the FF was the only franchise they took on. They utilized all the same talent from their other shows, with great voice acting, musical scores, sound effects and design work. The animation was a bit basic but very fun and you got to see the Thing punch out monsters, moloids, mobsters and Doctor Doom. Another thing it had going for it was that it had the advantage of adapting early FF comic stories from Stan Lee and Jack Kirby. This was huge because of the many positives with the Hanna Barbera shows, memorable stories weren’t one of them. Here, they started with good stories and animated them. They only produced 20 episodes total and ABC ran them for three years straight in reruns. All in all, a solid cartoon of the time. Not sure if it’s available anywhere but probably on YouTube. If you want to see stories based on classic Lee/Kirby FF comics, I’d recommend giving it a look. Interestingly, AT&T/Time-Warner (owners of DC comics) own the entire Hanna Barbera library, so this original FF cartoon is the *one* piece of Marvel that Disney does not own!

Fast forward to the late ’70’s and shield your eyes before the horror that is H.E.R.B.I.E.. Blame the DePatie Freling studio, blame Stan Lee, I don’t care. Whether it was a rights issue or the sublime idiot patrol who was always looking to protect children from every aspect of life including that fact that fire is dangerous, the Human Torch wasn’t in this cartoon. They replaced him with H.E.R.B.I.E. the annoying robot. What do the letters stand for? Well, considering how fast this show died due to the producer’s bad judgement — I don’t care. This was just unfortunate. But not THE most unfortunate FF related animated show to come out of the ’70’s.

No, that would be 1979’s, Fred and Barney meet The Thing, a one time episode (in which Fred and Barney DO NOT EVEN ACTUALLY MEET THE THING) which spun off into The Thing’s own show. Which lasted for two episodes. All I know about the Thing’s own show…. was that it featured a teenage Benji Grimm… who wore… a Thing Ring…. and when there was trouble…. Benji would yell at the top if his lungs…..
“Thing-Ring, do your thing!” And a bunch of orange rocks would fly in and cover him and then he was the Thing. I take it back, since this was also from HB, Warner’s probably owns this as well. They can keep it.
At this point, I think I *would* like to point a finger at Stan Lee. I defend Stan quite a bit regarding comics history but I’d like to think Stan at least raised a ruckus when some of these ridiculous decisions came down the pike. He may not have had much say but still. We also had years when Avi Arad was stinking up the joint as executive producer giving the green light to a lot of total garbage.
Moving on.
1994 saw New World entertainment and Genesis productions put out an all new FF cartoon. This was both the worst and the best of all possible worlds. There were two, 13 ep seasons. The first season made the Thing Ring chant look intelligent. It was utter nonsense. From the mindless theme song to the constant disrespect of the characters to insulting the intelligence of 7 year olds everywhere. It was DOA. Just horrible and silly. But then something amazing happened.

The powers that be saw they done wrong and totally revamped the show. They got good scripts, started adapting faithful versions of famous Lee and Kirby stories as well as ones from the John Byrne era. The animation was much much better too, with a different studio and they even had the one and only John Buscema –a giant in the comics industry –doing storyboards! The difference between seasons is day and night. They sell the whole package on DVD and I heartily recommend it as the second season alone is more than worth the price. It truly was nearly worthy of the Bruce Timm DC animated series stuff and you don’t get any better than that. That second season was and is one of if not the finest Marvel animated series to ever come out, period. There’ve been a ton of Spider-man and X-men series but none quite as good as season two of the FF. YMMV.
Speaking of not quite as good, starting in 2007, an American/Canadian/French company put forth a new version of the FF, called Fantastic Four, the World’s greatest heroes–with an anime look and feel. Over a span of three and a half years, they put out 27 eps. When the show premiered, I lasted all of ten minutes. The animation wasn’t bad but it’s clear this company knew almost nothing about the FF and desperately wanted to put their stamp on it. The story, personalities and dialog for the characters were aimed at a younger audience. The character designs left a lot to be desired as well. Red, white and blue costumes didn’t really say FF and the Thing just had long, baggy pants and a sloppily painted 4 on his chest. Some defend this as an overlooked, under appreciated cartoon. I would say these people might be into the anime angle and *as* a kind of dumbed down anime in look and feel, I guess that’s fine but there’s little of the actual FF in the mix. I can no more recommend this than I can the HERBIE debacle, just for different reasons.

I’m certain that the ’90’s cartoon may have been produced in part because of the doomed Roger Corman produced live action film that never saw the light of day. Ditto the 2007 international anime show probably tried to cash in on the Tim Story films from 2005 & ’07, even though the cartoon bore little resemblance to any version of the FF ever.

Now that Marvel has the movie rights back for the FF, we’ll see if there are any more animated attempts to try and cash in on that. With Disney in charge, I’m at least hopeful, because the thing IS.




















