Over in the United Kingdom, they love their game shows–I mean, “Panel Shows”. They’ve got loads of panel shows over there featuring celebrities who have fun matching wits with one another and there’s little emphasis on points.
Via the YouTube app on my tv, I’ve checked out a few of these, and in some of them, the dry wit is in fact SO dry, that thank heaven water is provided on set, lest the participants choke on their comedic stylings. Others focus so heavily on British politics and inside stuff that the humor’s sometimes lost on us outsiders.
But once in a while, you find that sweet spot. The show that appeals to many, yet never has to dumb it down. Where, though dry wit is appreciated, *quick* wit wins the day.
Would I Lie To You is one of my two favorite panel shows, which has seen 12 seasons so far. The set up is simple. There are two teams of three. One is always captained by David Mitchell (Peep Show, That Mitchell and Webb Look), with celebs on his left and right. The other team’s perennial captain is Lee Mack (Not Going Out), with his guest celebrity teammates. Rob Brydon is the host. The celebs take turns reading statements from cards they’re provided. The opposing team has to determine whether the statement is true or not, by asking the reader questions.
Now, the person reading the statement is either very familiar with the statement–however ridiculous it might seem, as it really happened to them and might try and sell it as if they’re uncertain or unfamiliar, to throw off the opposing team. OR… the statement is totally made up by the writers, and the celebrity has to quickly think on their feet to try and handle the barrage of questions coming their way, casually explaining away fiction as fact.
Now, the comedy hits from a lot of directions, as people try to bluff, double bluff and sometimes triple bluff their way out of these holes they’ve been plunged into. I’ll give two examples with Lee Mack, who might be the fastest wit on the show, barely bypassing Mitchell.
One– there’s a feature where there’s an item to be shown along with reading the statement. In this case, a large ring of keys, that Mack said were his. He knew what all of them were for except one. So, of course he had to name what each and every key was for, plus the odd bits and tags attached. What followed was Mack operating on all cylinders to come up with the appropriate doors, gates and hatches for each key and bit, right down to an odd attachment labeled “P.B.U.”. All the while, the other celebs, particularly Mitchell, are luxuriating in watching him try to wriggle out of the latest predicament he’s found himself in. It was a lie and those were not his keys but to see him tread water is hilarious.
Two– reading the card, Mack states that he’s come up with an ingenious way of remembering the names of all the Teletubbies, and the rest of the gang settle in to hear his mental machinations. Once again, the explanation sounds like last second BS but then, the opposing team has to vote on whether he’s lying or telling the truth and if he’s fooled them, his team gets the point. If not, they do.
It really is quite brilliant and simple at the same time.
There is also, “This is my…”, a feature where a stranger comes out and each member of a team has to explain who the person is.
“This is Jim, he’s the man who broke my son’s arm”
“This is Jim, a clown who once comforted me after a fire”
“This is Jim, he once landed on my roof”
Only one of the stories and relationship is true, but the opposing team has to figure out who, of the three is telling the truth, and it’s never simple.
It really is entertaining as all hell and even though you probably won’t recognize any of the celebrities–it doesn’t matter. Each and every one of them either gets chucked in the deep end or have to put on a deceptive and confident performance –or both–to fool the opposition.
My only regret is that they only do ten 30 minute shows a year but with 12 seasons, if you’re interested, you’ve got 120 eps waiting for you.
And that is the truth. Enjoy.











