Not bad.
Another well done…. well actually another well done set up story. It’s very different from doing just A Good Story, which has a beginning, a middle and an end.
Anyway, I think, pretty much top to bottom, that was a solid Doctor Who episode. Did my jaw drop and did it keep me on the edge of my seat? No, but it did keep me interested and I thought for once, the TARDIS crew acquitted themselves pretty well. And honestly, since this is the *fifth* set up episode out of a ten ep series, with no pay offs yet to be tendered, there’s only so much of it that’s *eligible* for critique. The most important elements to me, as always is the Doctor and companions in relation to the story. This particular story being yet another prelude, I have to focus more on the TARDIS crew. But as for what this story *did* give us…
I mean, last human colony, desperate times, desperate measures, thousands of dead Cybermen, thousands of dormant Cybermen, the lone Cyberman, the crew gets separated, basically a lot of urgency to grease the tracks and move things along quickly getting ready for next week. Then Gallifrey shows up and so does Nutty McMaster uttering cliches.
On to the crew:
Ryan. Since he’s leaving the show, I thought for sure he was a dead man early on when he bumbled right when he should have bumbled left. Then he was found by the Doctor and was basically Yaz for the rest of the ep, just decorating the corner being useless.
Yaz and Graham. This may have been the best acting I’ve seen from Gil so far and this was a rare instance where Chibs seemed to not do too badly with character interaction, at least on the escape ship anyway. And Graham was even getting hit on, which, since subtlety is never Chib’s strong suit, we might get a Leela/Andred pairing here next week. Heck, we might SEE Leela and Andred next week!
The Doctor. I have to give credit where credit’s due here. The Doctor has often been a careless jerk when it comes to the “fam” and in a burst of self realization, she owned up this week and admitted it, *finally* doing what she should have done last week and told them to get the hell out of there. Way way way too late of course but, eh. I can’t even say better late than never because they’re all in horrific danger now. But over all, aside from her small, wacky asides, Jodie’s best when she’s intense and the threat levels this week kept her very Doctorish in a good way.
And Brandon. When the ep began, and I started to watch this kid grow up, I thought oh man, this was going to be a tear jerking, heart string pulling, emotional one two punch… but no, I never did get attached to him and then he got old and somehow, his dad putting him in the conversion chair wasn’t even that powerful a moment. More of a head scratcher. We have car commercials that reduce me to tears in under 60 seconds when they show kids growing up and moving away (since I have kids) but here…. nothing. Maybe they’ll pay that off next week, along with Gallifrey, the Master, Doc Martin, the Cyberium plan, the Timeless Child and how everything we know is a lie and how this changes everything.
Basically, we’ve been seeing trailers, prologues, appetizers and previews all series. Next week, Chibs will have to give us the main event, main course, you name it. Because if next week is just another set up stringing us along for next season, I’m not going to be happy.
Finally, theory corner. I’m sure I’m not the only one who’s thinking that perhaps a sizable chunk of human civilization went through that gateway, the other side of which will turn out to be billions of years ago on what would one day be known as Gallifrey, and it’ll turn out that Time Lords are descended from humans.
I gotta say, yes, that *would* change everything and I would absolutely love it. If true, it’d be the biggest, ballsiest, gutsiest move maybe ever.
I wonder if Chibs is the one who actually thought of it?










