Gotta get this off my chest. Yeah, I know it’s just a stupid TV show, but I admire creativity and good writing and storytelling in my favorite show. When it goes to crap, I’m chiming in there as well.
Unlike some fans of Doctor Who, I did not abandon the show when Chris Chibnall took over as showrunner and brought in Jodie Whitaker as the Doctor. I’ve sat through them all and been mostly disappointed with S11. This series (12), has shown some improvement, as whether by hook or by crook, or BBC threat, certain things did improve a bit. Is it still a show worthy of the name Doctor Who? It has its moments.
One of the biggest problems it has is the disingenuous current Doctor. The blame is shared by Whitaker and Chibnall. Chibs mostly loads her lines up with meaningless platitudes, things a wacky Doctor *should* say and do, but they usually land flat because Chibnall doesn’t seem to have the faintest idea how people actually communicate. Whitaker, for her part, seldom lends the part any gravity, mostly just breathless chirping. But Chibs inability to write well for his characters mostly impacts the Doctor’s pets. I mean, human companions, who the Doctor is *always* referring to as her FAM. DYS FAM might be more appropriate.
This incarnation of the Doctor seems aware that she usually has had companions in the past, so *she* has them. Her FAM irritates her whenever they ask questions about her personal life. They traveled with her –unquestioningly — for two years, never thinking to actually ask who she is (!). They just meekly follow her around like obedient baby ducks, while she teaches them lessons. They have proven to be highly incapable and useless in every scenario.
The relationship with these people she dubbed her FAMILY, is more akin to this: say, your son is having friends stay over night at the house. Then the next day, for whatever reason, your son goes to school, but the friends go to another school and happens to have the day off, and you’ve got to drag them around on your errands. And you barely know them. That’s the “feel” here in today’s TARDIS.
The Doctor seemingly has no need or care for these people (her FAMILY). They don’t even seem that excited by the prospect of all the myriad wonders the universe shows them. Maybe because everywhere they go, they have this disconnected schoolmarm constantly lecturing them, morning, noon and night. You really get the feeling that they are in actuality, little more than an annoyance. This is all down to how Chibnall presents them and how Whitaker reacts in these scenarios.
The worst was this past Sunday in “Can You Hear Me?”, a story that started out decently enough with an interesting set up. An immortal creature making dreams come alive and torturing people in their dreams, etc. There was a message hidden within the narrative about mental health and how it’s good to talk to people. Suffice to say it wasn’t clear what any of the perceived ailments were and what was affliction and what was actually caused by the bald guy invading their dreams.
Sadly, this inability to tell a clear story, mixed with Chib’s inability to script real exchanges between characters, especially the Doctor’s “beloved” and “important” FAMILY came to a head at the end of the ep. Graham, played by beloved actor Bradley Walsh, was actually trying to have an important heart to heart conversation with the Doctor, talking earnestly about his fears regarding the possibility of his cancer coming back. He bared his soul to her. This was a moment. Between two people who’d been traveling together for years. Faced death together. A man the Doctor consider’s family. Any sincere or heartfelt reassurance, no matter how small, would have meant a lot.
She simply stared at him, then said, “I’m socially awkward. How about I just go over here and do some things and in a few minutes, you can pretend I said something good.” She basically treated Graham like some stranger at a bus stop. Abominable.
Some apologists for the show will say she’s alien, she doesn’t know better. Or this incarnation didn’t know any better. Nonsense. There’s nothing wrong with her memory of the last 2,000 years. She had 13 previous incarnations who were all alien, some tetchy, some rude and crude. But when the chips were down and the companion was in trouble, or needed to talk, the Doctor was always there and showed he cared. Always showed compassion.
Let’s take the example of twelfth Doctor, Peter Capaldi. That incarnation could be very rude and blunt to strangers. He could be brusque with anyone. But when Clara needed him, he was there with compassion. Clara’s boyfriend Danny had been killed and she was in a very bad place. She knocked out the Doctor with a sleeping drug, then gathered all the TARDIS keys and went to a volcano. When the Doctor woke, Clara shakily stated her intention that she would destroy all the keys unless the Doctor agreed to take her to heaven to bring Danny back. As I say, she was in bad shape. The Doctor managed to turn the tables on her, gained control of the scenario and said he’d help her. She was aghast. “After everything I’ve done?” And the Doctor responded: “Clara, do you think I care for you so little that betraying me would make a difference?” Now THAT’s a moment, that’s writing and that’s the Doctor. Been around over two thousand years and even with all the faults, the alien “otherness”, there is compassion.
Except, evidently, with the current incarnation. Ironically, she’s just a dick. A disingenuous, extraterrestrial creep who has shown she doesn’t care one whit about these lowly pets she carts around. I expect better.














